Carney isn't a terrible pundit. She's usually spot on with her observations and clearly does a bit of research on players/teams. She called everything right today apart from the handball stuff, but so was everyone else.
She did a great piece on the difference between Doc/Semedo link up with Traore. And then she said we needed to get players closer to Jose. Both turned out to be true because once Traore moved that opened up space for Semedo, and the two wide players playing narrower worked too.
Commentary is a different issue, she's a bit bland on that but then again so are lots of people.