As a left back
He was with us for just under 10 years.
For the first 3 he was pretty much irrelevant- apart from Lycan who was the first passenger on the hate train
For the next 3 he was awful, overweight and on occasion uninterested
The next average at best - like many before it the POTS vote was a joke
For the final 3 seasons he was good, how good he was or wasn't depends on how far to the various extremes you want to play up or down those performances. For me he had a very specific role he did well. It was clear he wouldn't be able to do another for us or anyone else. From that team that finished 7th he was one of a couple of players who obviously needed to be upgraded if we were to kick on. I'm not going down the 2 wormholes of did we get the value and whether we did upgrade again.
I don't want him back.