Refereeing question

[Lord Knows]

Don't think you need a message from the ref for that. Pretty obvious really isn't it...

I dont think so, players are not the brightest at times and with the game becoming so quick with the likelihood of a second booking more prevalent refs could offer that assistance. Think Daryl Janmaat.
I wonder if in time we will see a three card system.

 

[The Bear]

The manager can see that a player needs to be taken off, just like Wenger did with Coquelin.

 

[Deutsch Wolf]

On the subject of high boots, I did enjoy that simpleton Steve Cotterill asserting that the Brentford lad "shouldn't have put his head there".

Newsflash for George Ndah, it wasn't Matt Carbon's fault after all, you shouldn't have put your leg there.

 

[PuntsWolf]

I dont think so, players are not the brightest at times and with the game becoming so quick with the likelihood of a second booking more prevalent refs could offer that assistance. Think Daryl Janmaat.
I wonder if in time we will see a three card system.

It irrelevant what the player thinks, managers make the substitutions!

Players who aren't very bright, they are the ones who get sent off. Players who have a modicum of intelligence realise they are on a tight rope so they don't go to ground, and don't drag players back. Comings together aren't bookings, but when you are pushing it via the Accumulation of fouls, the manager should intervene unless he is totally stupid.

The manager can see that a player needs to be taken off, just like Wenger did with Coquelin.

Exactly

 

[optimistic wolf]

What a the rules regarding the technical area?, Steve Bruce spent hardly any of the game within the confines of his.

There were several critical calls in tonight's game and Michael Oliver got them all correct. He, Mark Clattenberg, and Mike Dean are the top three referees at the moment.

Sent from my LT26i using Tapatalk

 

[The Bear]

On the subject of high boots, I did enjoy that simpleton Steve Cotterill asserting that the Brentford lad "shouldn't have put his head there".

Newsflash for George Ndah, it wasn't Matt Carbon's fault after all, you shouldn't have put your leg there.

Fucking hell, ho can you defend that? Is that Freeman btw?

 

[FrankMunro-371]

Do Premier league refs ever pass on a message through the fourth official to tell a manager to replace a certain player if they would like to keep the game eleven a side.
Francis Coquelin comes to mind.

No they would not do that. If a player oversteps the mark, then he will be dealt with accordingly. Having said that, it does happen in friendlies.

 

[Deutsch Wolf]

Fucking hell, ho can you defend that? Is that Freeman btw?

Yeah. I mean Adrian's was a definite red at the weekend (and Bilic admitted it), that is even worse.

 

[The Bear]

I'm not sure Adrian deserved a red. It wasn't above stomach height and he didn't realise the player was there.

Same with Fernandinho. He didn't lead with his elbow and was watching the ball. Just caught Costa accidentally.

I think in those situations a red shouldn't be dished out if it was truly accidental contact.

 

[FrankMunro-371]

Having seen the sendings off in the Liverpool v West Ham United game, I think Kevin Friend possibly got them wrong, particularly the Noble dismissal. But there again, that is easy for me to say watching it from the comfort of my lounge.

 

[Kenny]

Noble's was never a red.

Coutinho, well he got a 2nd yellow for the attempted challenge. He wasn't helped by being made to look a tit. I guess the ref took the view he wasn't fully in control of the challenge.

 

[FrankMunro-371]

Agreed Kenny. Noble will appeal, and really should win his appeal.

 

[Donegal Wolf]

Chris Baird lost the plot tonight and got two yellow cards in the same sequence of play, first of all he bumped into an Hungarian player and left his foot in, the ref played advantage and as Hungary counter attacked he took down the Hungarian forward, both clear yellow card offences, so the ref gave him 2 yellows.

Looks like Baird was shocked, I think he thought he could be only done for one offence in the play, must admit I had never seen it before.

 

[Deutsch Wolf]

Good refereeing I say, both were clear yellow card offences.

 

[Kenny]

Good refereeing I say, both were clear yellow card offences.

The ref in that game was superb through out. Always looked to play advantage and let the game flow.

 

[Lord Knows]

Howard Webb says referees "generally supportive " of a video assistant and want to see a live trial.

 

[FrankMunro-371]

I did not see the incident, but apparently Baird walked away from the referee when the first caution was being issued, so I wonder if the second caution was for that.

 

[darlowolf64]

I did not see the incident, but apparently Baird walked away from the referee when the first caution was being issued, so I wonder if the second caution was for that.

If that was the case, there will be a lot of players sent off every game if every referee adopts this approach

 

[MARKakaJIM]

I did not see the incident, but apparently Baird walked away from the referee when the first caution was being issued, so I wonder if the second caution was for that.

He only walked a couple of steps after the first card had been shown, no different to any player who's committed that sort of foul to stop a counter attack wanting to get into position, then he got made to look a dick when the ref called him back for other yellow which must have been for lashing out at someone off the ball, mindless stuff.

 

[Deutsch Wolf]

It wasn't, it was for two fouls. Just the first one had been let go as advantage was played.