Tony Towner
Well-known member
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2010
- Messages
- 38,248
- Reaction score
- 24,552
Didn't really work at BluesAnd I think he'd look fantastic in there too. I don't think Saiss and N'Daiye would be a bad partnership either.
Didn't really work at BluesAnd I think he'd look fantastic in there too. I don't think Saiss and N'Daiye would be a bad partnership either.
Didn't really work at Blues
I like him, I'd play him ahead of Saiss now even if he were fit as he gets into the box more and with teams largely parking the bus that's what we need. In that game though they just didn't work, it would concern me if one of Neves' two games was against one of the top 6.N’Diaye has been pretty good for us, but definitely had an off day against Blues.
I like him, I'd play him ahead of Saiss now even if he were fit as he gets into the box more and with teams largely parking the bus that's what we need. In that game though they just didn't work, it would concern me if one of Neves' two games was against one of the top 6.
N'Daiye & Saiss will do a decent job against most that the Championship can throw at us
N'Diaye works so well because when he's playing we end up in effectively a 3-3-4 formation, and a combination of a great defence and a midfield of Ruben Neves means we can push that many bodies forward in this league. Now that more and more teams are trying just to shut up shop against us and aim for a point, it suits us, but I don't think we can get away with it in the Premier League. I think Saiss is better suited to make the step up in this system, imo.
I can't atop watching that Neves goal, it's one of the best goals I've ever seen.
Unless you are playing them as one of your front 2 and even then I don't think it would suit any of them particularly well then you aren't playing Jota, Cav or Costa in either of those formations. 451 could be an alternative, but I think Jota would lose something from his game as an out and out left midfielder/ winger. Ultimately the formation we play now is the best suited to the players we have (except Afobe) and enables us to get more of our better players on the pitch at the same time.N'Diaye + Saiss is obviously a minor step below Neves + either, but I truly think that as a pair they're still better than half of what gets played in the Prem.
Without Neves we'd lose a bit of magic but I don't think we'd be significantly worse off. We're far too well coached.
Not that I think we should change things but I'd be mildly curious as to how much control we could exert if we played a 5-3-2/3-5-2 (depending on your perspective) with N'Diaye + Saiss + Neves. That's a top flight trio in every respect, not a doubt in my mind.
Jota was better...
Apples and Oranges for me, Clive.
Indeed, just prefer to see a team goal over a wonder strike.
The ball from Coady and control from Cav were a big factor in Neves goal too