Hello everyone, new poster here but have been lurking for a while. Recently got back from the game so here were my thoughts.
Ruddy - Awful first half. Made a hash of Swift's long range effort in the first minute, could have gone in, almost cost us a goal when he tried to pass out and it got blocked going just wide. Dropped a cross at the start of the second half leading to a scramble but then went on to make some good saves, one of the ones from Barrow was superb. 7/10
Vinagre - More than adequate replacement for Douglas. Solid defensively and always impressed by his dribbling and technique. Beat his man for pace a few times and put some good crosses in. 8/10.
Boly - My MOTM. So calm and composed at the back, threw himself at the ball time and time again to block a shot or hack away a cross. Attackers barely got the beating of him one-on-one and it's so refreshing to see a centre-back who can run with the ball and pass it without just lumping it out for a throw-in. Great block on the line too. 9/10.
Coady - Made some good interceptions/blocks/clearances. Came out with the ball a few times and made some decent long passes. 8/10.
Bennett - Admittedly I am not keen on him but he was mostly solid. Smacked the ball away and cost us possession a few times when I think he could have played it out from the back instead. Got a yellow card for taking out Aluko when it looked like he was on a dangerous run. At fault for Reading's best chance by not stopping the pass to Kermorgant which led to Barrow's chance which he should have scored. 7/10.
Doherty - Took his goal well. Good with his running, and picked out with the pass by Saiss/Neves as usual though his crossing was poor and often made the wrong choice in the pass. Defensively solid, got booked for diving (looked like he did). 8/10.
Saiss - Neat and tidy for most of the game though late on like a few others kept giving the ball away. A few good passes but not his best game. 6/10.
Neves - Same as Saiss really but kept the ball a bit better. Offered more going forward. 7/10.
Cavaleiro - Had a very good game, particularly in the first half, Ilori couldn't handle him and ended up getting subbed off after 30 minutes. Made some dangerous runs and was unlucky not to score again. Goal was superbly taken, wonderful bit of skill. 8/10.
Bonatini - Didn't get on the ball much, link-up play was OK. Went agonisingly close with a shot right before being subbed off. 6/10.
Jota - Brilliant assist, and almost set Cav up for a second. Good in the first half but faded in the second. 6.5/10
Bright - I find him so frustrating. Yes he has ability but he makes the wrong decision far too often. Gave the ball away and offered nothing. Like the Preston game I find the decision to bring him on for Bonatini odd. 3/10.
Costa - This was a far better showing off the bench than what I have seen previously. Good with his running and looked much sharper. Made a good run to beat three men and then his run to set up the goal for Doherty was great. Only 15 minutes but his best performance of the season for me. 7/10.
N'Diaye - Similar to Preston, brought on when there was a lot of pressure on us. Can't remember him doing much though, and before the second goal we were just generally terrible at keeping the ball. 5/10.
Ref was OK. No complaints about Bennet's card and it looked like Doherty dived to me. Linos missed one obvious throw-in our way and what looked like a Reading corner when Ruddy let the ball go out after a save but otherwise no real complaints.
Reading can feel unlucky to have lost this one, draw would have been a fair result in my opinion. Not sure how they haven't scored but was impressed by how they played, even with Dave Edwards in the side. Aluko and Barrow were big threats but we did manage to contain them. Well done and looking forward to Wednesday.