2005 was a different time! This was pre-Dez Bryant and that debacle, and frankly it’s been a net negative IMO. Used to be that the offensive player got the benefit of the doubt much more often. “Complete the process” wasn’t even a twinkle in a referee’s eye.
The way they ruled in the end was that he had control with the ball in his hands and pressed against Faulk’s back, then down at (I think) the 3 yard line when his helmet touched. So once he was down, the little flub at the end where he absolutely loses control becomes irrelevant.
That was on 4th and 13 just before halftime, and Southern Miss were in control. It would have been an awful loss, especially at home. Prothro rescued some confidence with that catch, and we went on to win comfortably. I was 14 and couldn’t have been more obsessed. When Tyrone broke his leg just a couple of weeks later (truly grotesque; I wouldn’t recommend searching for it, but it’s easily found), I didn’t recover for a month at least. Ended his career.
Ah, memories.