Deutsch Wolf
Sponsored by Amazon Prime. DM me for discounts...
- Joined
- Oct 16, 2009
- Messages
- 109,272
- Reaction score
- 35,435
If we say their strongest team (not necessarily what Pulis has been picking) is something like:
---------------Foster-------------
Nyom-----Evans---Dawson----Gibbs
-------Krychowiak---Barry--------
----Phillips-----Chadli-----Brunt
---------------Rondon----------------
Then I suppose you could argue he's right if we're only talking in definitive terms (as in, I would definitely take Jota over Brunt or Burke, Neves over Barry/Livermore/Yacob and Boly over Dawson/McAuley/Hegazi). But then I wouldn't see the point in swapping Foster for Ruddy or Phillips for Cav/Costa. I would say Costa has the highest ceiling of any of those three players. We don't play a #10 so can't really swap Chadli for anyone in that sense - Rondon might well have been ruined by over two years of Pulis' football so who knows with him.
Nyom is 100% a better RB than Doherty and Gibbs obviously has way more pedigree than either Douglas or Vinagre, but then we don't play full backs, so not an exact match.
If Pulis had stayed and we'd drawn them in the cup in January then I think we'd have beaten them.
---------------Foster-------------
Nyom-----Evans---Dawson----Gibbs
-------Krychowiak---Barry--------
----Phillips-----Chadli-----Brunt
---------------Rondon----------------
Then I suppose you could argue he's right if we're only talking in definitive terms (as in, I would definitely take Jota over Brunt or Burke, Neves over Barry/Livermore/Yacob and Boly over Dawson/McAuley/Hegazi). But then I wouldn't see the point in swapping Foster for Ruddy or Phillips for Cav/Costa. I would say Costa has the highest ceiling of any of those three players. We don't play a #10 so can't really swap Chadli for anyone in that sense - Rondon might well have been ruined by over two years of Pulis' football so who knows with him.
Nyom is 100% a better RB than Doherty and Gibbs obviously has way more pedigree than either Douglas or Vinagre, but then we don't play full backs, so not an exact match.
If Pulis had stayed and we'd drawn them in the cup in January then I think we'd have beaten them.