Paddingtonwolf
Flaming Galah
- Joined
- Oct 30, 2009
- Messages
- 78,127
- Reaction score
- 8,375
Injured.
I don't know, we signed Donk as an up and coming 23 year old with a good reputation who was playing for a top International side.
This guy has just been relegated with Albion and played for one of the worst sides at the Euros?
You think Lage signs the players?Fuck all of this, where is our new centre back, we need one oh so badly, is Lage asleep or what ?
You made a comparison with the Dendoncker signing, i was giving you reasons why i disagreed, being an integral part of a side that got relegated and a part of side that were regarded as dark horses but were shite in an international side are fair reasons as to why i think you're wrong to compare him with the Dendoncker signing.Being in a relegated team doesn't mean you're shit/it's your fault. Areola and Anderson had admirers on here, for a start. Likewise, you can't help if your international team is crap.
Yep agreed, it's a good price for that level of player.No idea if he’s any good, not going to pretend I watched him for Albion or in Spain, but heard the reports that he was a standout for them, admittedly a low bar. But even if he’s only Doncks equal (peak donck that is, if it still exists) I’d sign him simply because we do need another body in there, he’s cheap and fits the style of player we need.
Probably not the player we should be signing to have a crack at the top 7, but with our budget that’s not a realistic immediate aim. But it does fit the steady experienced player to help alongside inexperienced youth.
You're an optimist!This guy is probably the backup plan if the main targets don't come off.
I don’t think Nuno did him any favours, tbf.Let's face it, Donk excels at pretty much nothing. There's 'playing several positions', and there's doing it well. And Yokuslu is 27 not 29.
You made a comparison with the Dendoncker signing, i was giving you reasons why i disagreed, being an integral part of a side that got relegated and a part of side that were regarded as dark horses but were shite in an international side are fair reasons as to why i think you're wrong to compare him with the Dendoncker signing.
If his international side was crap, you'd expect him to shine, he didn't. if Dendoncker was shite you'd expect him not to get picked for a very good international side ever, but he does and did when we signed him.
Dendoncker who also upon on signing was a younger player who had Champions league experience and International experience for a side that got to the last 4 in the World Cup.
I just don't think it's comparable at all.
I also don't think Dendoncker has got to the level i expected him to either, i had much higher hopes, particularly after his first and second seasons. Hopefully we'll see him return to that this season.
The signing at the time was progressive and ambitious.Yet you make Donk sound awesome... I wish I'd seen some of this ambitious, next level signing when he's pulled on a Wolves shirt, but really he's just been average at best
I think he played less than half because he only came in on loan in January if memory serves me correctly. Didn't see him play myself but heard Albion improved alot after he came into the side and they wouldn't have been relegated on their form with him in the side.I think you're using a heavy dollop of spin on both players here.
Didn't Yoklusu play less than half of Albion's games? Not sure that makes you integral, and I don't think his reputation came out of it too badly either. I got the impression he was one of their better players.
Yet you make Donk sound awesome... I wish I'd seen some of this ambitious, next level signing when he's pulled on a Wolves shirt, but really he's just been average at best
We signed Donk just after the World Cup, not sure how Donk performed in the Euros has anything to do with how the two compare as signings at the time.The Belgium thing doesn't stand up either really. He started the Euros for them wasn't great and ended up getting replaced by a player past his best in Witsel.
Belgium do weird things anyway, they started Vermaelen in one of the games, Chadli still gets in the squad as well.
So? That's irrelevant to the discussion.Vermaelen, Vertonghen, Chadli, Mignolet, Benteke, Batshuayi and Boyata were all in the Belgian Euro squad
I'd say how players play is more important than how signings are perceived.We signed Donk just after the World Cup, not sure how Donk performed in the Euros has anything to do with how the two compare as signings at the time.
All i've argued is that Donk was a higher profile signing than Yoksulu would be, as to me it's ridiculous to say otherwise. How Donk has performed since is irrelevant.