[FA Cup 3rd Rnd] Liverpool 2-2 Wolves: Verdict Thread

[Del Woppio]

The fucking idiots have given the offside for the Collins header not the second header..

Toti says he was told at full time that he was "a bit offside"

 

[jd1981]

I’m beyond confused and it just shows where the game is when seasoned football fans can no longer understand what is or isn’t offside.
Have they flagged for Collins header? If so is the fact Hwang tried to head and got a touch create a new phase of play?
As some have said the ref thinks it looks off and has told the assistant to get his flag up and then let VAR deal with it.
Reality is assistant view is better and should be trusted.
Problem with VAR is it doesn’t let the VAR official use any common sense.
They’re clearly using proof beyond reasonable doubt threshold.

 

[Johnny75]

Think that's Quirk's point

They surely can't be that stupid.

 

[Deutsch Wolf]

Toti says he was told at full time that he was "a bit offside"

Up there with whoever told James Corden "you can sing a bit".

 

[Kenny]

Toti says he was told at full time that he was "a bit offside"

When Nunes puts in his cross after the Hwang header; he is off...but the Liverpool defender cuts it out (nowhere near to Toti) and we get the ball back and then play the ball than onside Toti....but if that was the one that had the camera angles for it.

 

[Del Woppio]

I suspect he's flagged for Toti, and then they've just guessed at something to prove a flag was the right thing to do

 

[jd1981]

I suspect he's flagged for Toti, and then they've just guessed at something to prove a flag was the right thing to do

If it’s Toti he flagged for that could easily be seen by VAR that it was onside. If they don’t think Nunes is off and haven’t flagged for him the goal should stand.
The more you look at it the more it looks like Andy Madley has made a huge balls up.

 

[PuntsWolf]

If it’s Toti he flagged for that could easily be seen by VAR that it was onside. If they don’t think Nunes is off and haven’t flagged for him the goal should stand.
The more you look at it the more it looks like Andy Madley has made a huge balls up.

It’s fucking shit and a right fuck up but the one thing that hasn’t happened is Andy Madley has decided it’s offside.

 

[Deutsch Wolf]

Here's the one you want to pin on Madley. It's a penalty.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1611851484341092352

 

[Kenny]

Here's the one you want to pin on Madley. It's a penalty.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1611851484341092352

Just after that the ITV cameras were showing Lopetegui and in the background Ronan was telling someone "that was a foul".

Seems VAR should have used our cameras instead of theirs/ITV's

 

[PuntsWolf]

Here's the one you want to pin on Madley. It's a penalty.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1611851484341092352

Was a stonewall foul and in the game I didn’t realise it was in the box. Was only afterwards I saw it was in the box and then knew that was why he didn’t give it. Gives a foul for that 100/100 anywhere else on the pitch.

 

[Kenny]

Don't think ITV even showed a replay of the incident did they?

 

[Alan]

Looks worse every time I see it. Not even reviewed.

 

[jd1981]

If VAR did look at it and said not enough contact I’d still be fuming the fact they didn’t just highlights the incompetence of Mike Dean who will be in place again this weekend picking up a nice wage.

 

[PuntsWolf]

They’d have checked it but Mike Dean sides with the ref every single time unless you two foot someone to the face. So he’d have one look and then wave it off.

 

[Alan]

My read is that Dean has seen the little look Cunha gives the defender who is about to foul him and has decided "oh, that means he's just going to dive when the defender arrives".

 

[Paddingtonwolf]

My read is Dean is a cunt

 

[Deano]

I like the small amount I've seen of Cunha so far, he makes runs that pull defenders away and creates room, he did it for Adamas chance vs Villa and again in this game, got the assist for Hwangs goal and as said above should have had a penalty. I don't think he's going to be prolific but I think he's going to be a good option anywhere in the front 3.

 

[Elephant Pyjamas]

Don't think ITV even showed a replay of the incident did they?

No, but we got a super, super, super slow mo of Gakpo doing a pretty average turn in the first half.

 

[WsWolf]

Don't think ITV even showed a replay of the incident did they?

I was absolutely seething at this at the time. Not even looked at but it's a foul 100/100