Might revisit this thread over the winter months if time allows.
For brevity, a couple of revisited LPs;
Elbow - Little Fictions - ok not as old as the OP suggests, but actually a very good album. Been enjoying it.
Lo Fidelity Allstars - Have revisited their 2nd and third albums (Don't Be Afraid of Love, and Northern Stomp) and have to say both are better than I remember. I absolutely adored their first album, and LPs 2 and 3 had a slightly different line up, and tone. As a result, younger me always chose the debut album, but have really enjoyed listening to both of these, as there's a few bangers, guest appearances from the likes of Greg Dulli, and a strong northern soul influence.