I thought Maguire was well respected and what he says is considered accurate?
The accounts he’s analysing are stating we were £20m under PSR limit. That was never really in doubt.
This year I think everyone fully accepts we’ve got to/had to “balance the books”.
But fag packet maths say our purchases increased amortisation by at most £10m. Nunes and Collins sales reduced the amortisation by £13m.
Let’s say Raul was break even on fee/amortistaion, so ignore him. Adama reduces by about £3m
So amortisation has come down by minimim £6m.
Neves/Coady/Giles sales pure profit of £60m.
We will ignore loan fees. Let’s say Collins was no profit, but one years amortisation so £4m. Nunes 1 year amortisation plus £10m = £18m. Add all that togerher and it’s a conservative £82m on player trading.
Wages have clearly come down. Income has come up, but we will ignore both as we don’t know. So if we assume all things are the same bar amortisation and player trading.
Amortisation down £6m minimum.
Profit on player sales £82m. Which im going to estimate as £42m more than the previous season.
So the accounts should be at worst £48m better in player trading. Add a decrease in wages and increases in income then I think we should have more than comfortably balanced them to have allowed some form of spending in January.